SEO Visibility For Attorneys In An AI World

Table of Contents

• What’s Changed in SEO for Attorneys?

• The Rise of Zero-Click Searches

• Quality Over Quantity: What LLM Traffic Means for Law Firms

• Modern Search Behavior: It’s Not Just Google Anymore

• Why Neil Patel Says SEO Is Now Search Everywhere Optimization

• Where to Focus Your Website SEO in 2025

• What Metrics Matter in This New SEO Landscape

• How to Help LLMs Cite Your Legal Content

• Where AI Models Source Content — and How to Be Seen

• Backlinks in an AI-Driven World

• Paid Ads: Bridging the Visibility Gap

• Using LLMs for Content Ideation

• Final Thoughts

What’s Changed in SEO for Attorneys?

Quick Answer: SEO for attorneys has shifted dramatically due to the influence of AI. Law firms must now:

• Optimize across multiple platforms (not just Google).

• Focus on content that engages after the click.

• Make their content easily scannable and LLM-friendly.

• Make an extra effort to capture client reviews, ideally including the type of service provided, to capture those keywords.

• Create long-form answers that answer niche queries with conversion intent.

• Adapt to how different AI platforms find and serve content.

Let’s dive into the details of how your law firm can thrive in this new environment.

The Rise of Zero-Click Searches

A study by SEO guru Rand Fishkin at SparkToro revealed that over 50% of all Google searches now end in zero clicks. That means people find the answers they’re looking for directly in search results, never visiting a single website. This was confirmed during the recent Google Search documents leak on Github by the yoshi-code-bot automated bot.

This poses a huge challenge for attorneys who depend on web traffic to generate leads. However, it’s also an opportunity: law firms that position themselves as the source behind those zero-click answers can still gain brand awareness and trust.

Example: A search for "how to file for divorce in Florida" might now display an AI snippet with a link to a YouTube video, or possibly a long-form article. If your content answers this in a clear, direct, well-structured format, your firm might be cited — and even if the user doesn’t click, they now know your name.

Check out this chart on how Google's AI Overviews have reduced clickthrough rates on #1 ranked pages by 34.5% in March 2025.  Some websites have seen clicks reduced by 20-40% since the rollout of AI Overviews.

Quality Over Quantity: What LLM Traffic Means for Law Firms

As traffic from traditional search declines, LLMs (like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity) are ushering in a new kind of visitor — one who’s already done their research.

These users are more likely to:

• Be closer to making a decision.

• Have highly specific questions.

• Appreciate clarity, trustworthiness, and experience.

Example: Instead of searching "how to choose a personal injury lawyer," they’re asking, "What’s the statute of limitations for car accidents in Miami, Florida?" If your content answers that concisely, you become the trusted source.

Modern Search Behavior: It’s Not Just Google Anymore

Search is now multi-platform, multi-format, and often context-driven. Here’s how your potential clients are discovering legal help today:

Platforms:

• Google and Bing: Still dominate, in particularly Google which controls 90% of traditional search engine traffic, but include more AI summaries and instant answers.

• LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity): Used for deep dives and nuanced legal questions.

• YouTube: People want to see and hear from a real attorney to answer questions before they book a consultation.

• Reddit & Other Forums: Seeking honest, unfiltered, peer-to-peer advice and reviews.

• Social Media (LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok): Discovery through micro influencers, and possibly you, if your content is strong enough.

Behaviors:

• Users now search with conversational context. For example, “Is a prenup enforceable if I signed it under pressure?” instead of “prenup legal advice.”

• Many start on social or YouTube, research on Google, and make decisions via ChatGPT. According to TechCrunch, nearly half of Gen Z users (ages 18-24) go to TikTok or Instagram to search, rather than Google, although clearly this percentage is higher for restaurants than for attorneys. It does, however, underscore the behavioral shift toward socials we’re seeing in younger generations.

Tip: Claim and optimize your profiles everywhere your audience is — including Google My Business, Avvo, and YouTube. 

Be on Reddit to understand what potential clients are asking. Answer questions authentically, but do not sound like you’re promoting your firm, or the community will jump all over you. If you’re helpful, they will see your profile and connect.

Why Neil Patel Says SEO Is Now Search Everywhere Optimization

Marketing thought leader Neil Patel coined the term Search Everywhere Optimization to reflect today’s reality: visibility must span platforms, formats, and even devices.

For attorneys, this means:

• Being findable via text, video, audio, and community posts.

• Showing up on Reddit threads, YouTube videos, LLM results, and local listings.

• Using your website as your authority hub — but not your only channel.

Example: A criminal defense attorney can record short YouTube videos answering questions, repost the transcript as a blog, summarize it in a Reddit AMA, and then ensure it's summarized for Gemini.

Where to Focus Your Website SEO in 2025

Your website is still the anchor of your digital presence. But the way you optimize it has to align with current behaviors and technologies:

1. Page Speed

• Compress images, clean up code, use caching.

• Aim for under 3 seconds load time on mobile.

2. Mobile Optimization

• Most legal searches happen on mobile.

• Use large text, simple CTAs, click-to-call buttons.

3. User Intent Matching

• Use tools like SEMrush or Google Search Console to discover what your audience is actually looking for.

• Create landing pages for each stage of the funnel — from awareness to conversion. Although the landing page may not receive the same amount of traffic it did previously as part of your funnel, you still need landing pages to feed AI. For attorneys, this means a service page for each area of law you practice. For example, a business attorney may want services pages for business litigation & debt collection, intellectual property law, tax & financial law, mergers & acquisitions, etc. This distinct content is easier for LLMs and search engines to reference.

4. Content Architecture

• Add a sidebar table of contents to your blogs to help users click through long-form content.

• Use anchor links, FAQs, bulleted lists, and summaries at the top.

Example: A bankruptcy law firm could build a “Should I file for Chapter 7 or 13?” page with a clear TOC, quick summary bullet list, and then detailed legal context below.

What Metrics Matter in This New SEO Landscape

It’s no longer enough to get the click — you must keep attention. Google, and AI models, now reward content that performs after the click.

Track and optimize for:

• Time on site: Are people reading or bouncing?

• Pages per visit: Are users exploring your site?

• Bounce rate: High bounce? Revisit the layout and content clarity.

• Heatmaps/scroll depth: Use tools like Hotjar. They even have a free version with limited page visits that can provide insights.

Example: If most users scroll only halfway through your personal injury FAQ page, test adding a summary at the top or inserting a video halfway down.

How to Help LLMs Cite Your Legal Content

Want to show up in AI summaries? Help the models help you:

Structure Matters

• Start with the question and answer it immediately.

• Follow with details, case examples, statutes, and context.

Use Skimmable Formats

• Sidebar table of contents

• Top-of-page summary bullets

• Bolded key phrases

• FAQ sections

Add Schema Markup

• Use FAQ, Article, and LegalService schema to help machines understand your content.

Show Trust Signals

• Reviews on Google, Avvo, and Yelp

• Case studies and testimonials

• Attorney bios with credentials and media appearances

Tip: Ask your intake team what questions prospects always ask. Turn those into long-tail pages and blog posts.

Where AI Models Source Content — and How to Be Seen

Each LLM pulls data from different places. Here’s where you need to be:

ChatGPT (OpenAI)

• Wikipedia, .gov, .edu, peer-reviewed articles

• Your blog could be cited if you’re quoted in trusted publications or government-adjacent platforms

Gemini (Google)

• YouTube, Reddit, Google’s own index

• Prioritize high-quality, short-form legal video and Reddit AMAs

Perplexity

• Niche blogs, subreddits, forum posts

• Start a blog, answer niche legal questions in depth, and engage on Reddit

Example: An immigration attorney who writes thoughtful Reddit replies and publishes explainer videos on YouTube is more likely to be cited by Gemini (and therefore the Google AI snippet) and Perplexity.

Backlinks in an AI-Driven World

Backlinks still matter — but only if they drive engagement.

A link from a top legal directory that no one clicks? Low value. A link from a guest article that gets reshared and engaged with? High value.

Tip: Partner with law schools, legal influencers, or local news outlets to publish articles that attract both backlinks and readers.

Paid Ads: Bridging the Visibility Gap

Organic search may never recover to previous levels — but that’s okay.

Use ads strategically to:

• Launch new practice areas

• Promote gated content (e.g., “Car Accident Claim Checklist”)

• Target high-conversion keywords no longer generating traffic from SEO, or retarget past visitors

Example: A family law firm could run YouTube pre-roll ads that appear on videos titled “How to File for Custody in Florida.” The firm should also have a robust YouTube channel with value added content that matches searches.

Using LLMs for Content Ideation

Here’s a secret weapon: ask the LLMs themselves.

Try Prompts Like:

• “What are the top 10 questions people ask about divorce in Florida?”

• “What questions are people asking Chatgpt before hiring a criminal defense attorney?”

• “What legal questions are trending in Miami on Reddit?”

Build content around what people are actually asking, not what you think they might want.

Pro Tip: Include these queries as H2s and answer them in short, clear blocks.

Final Thoughts

In an AI-dominated world, SEO for attorneys is less about chasing Google’s algorithm and more about:

• Being discoverable everywhere your clients look.

• Building authority with smart, structured, useful content.

• Driving engagement that turns curiosity into consultations.

The firms that win won’t be the ones with the most keywords — they’ll be the ones that create content that humans love and AI understands.

Let your expertise shine. Make it easy to find, easy to trust, and easy to act on.